- Jeff Hirbour
- Â Cal Carr 25 episodes, 2010-2015
- Jenny Ashman
- Â Lucy / ... 19 episodes, 2010-2015
- Thomas Bigley
- Â Hermes 18 episodes, 2010-2015
- Caleb Claxton
- Â Poseidon / ... 15 episodes, 2011-2015
- Jake Brown
- Â Jake James / ... 14 episodes, 2010-2013
- Virginia Welch
- Â Scarlett Ray 10 episodes, 2010-2013
- Sean Pritchett
- Â Hades 9 episodes, 2013-2015
- Aurelia Scheppers
- Â Aphrodite 8 episodes, 2010-2013
- Diane Chernansky
- Â Serafina 7 episodes, 2015
- Brittany Ortiz-Nelson
- Â Isis 7 episodes, 2015
- Paige Sturges
- Â Gaia / ... 7 episodes, 2015
- Laurie Scott
- Â Megan Sullivan 7 episodes, 2010-2011
- Tom MacDonald
- Â Tori the Minotaur 7 episodes, 2010-2011
- Rachel Sleek-Banuelos
- Â Kristen Kole 6 episodes, 2013
- Reid Cox
- Â Cherry 6 episodes, 2013
- Brandon Gilbrech
- Â Ned / ... 6 episodes, 2011-2015
- Charles Pasternak
- Â Billy Shakespeare 6 episodes, 2010-2015
- Bryant Romo
- Â Sebastian Eros 6 episodes, 2010-2011
- Tristin Daley
- Â Athena 5 episodes, 2013
- A.J. Diamond
- Â Jesus / ... 5 episodes, 2013-2015
- Cheryl Texiera
- Â The Sphinx 5 episodes, 2011
- Mikel Miller
- Â Yahweh 4 episodes, 2015
- Robert Paterno
- Â Buddha 4 episodes, 2015
- Scott Hartman
- Â Pablo / ... 4 episodes, 2010-2011
- John Fowler
- Â Odin 3 episodes, 2015
- Ryan Penington
- Â Cameraguy 3 episodes, 2013
- Matt Hucke
- Â Stoneman #2 / ... 3 episodes, 2011-2013
- Max Broude
- Â Stoneman Marc Antony 3 episodes, 2011
- Christina MacKinnon
- Â Circe 2 episodes, 2013
- Kate O'Toole
- Â Bartender 2 episodes, 2013
- Eliza Kiss
- Â Zoe the Mermaid 2 episodes, 2015
- Scotch Hopkins
- Â Ares 2 episodes, 2013
- Elizabeth Holcomb
- Â Scarlett Ray 2 episodes, 2010
- Johnny Vieira
- Â Stoneman #4 2 episodes, 2011
- Brian Maples
- Â Stoneman Paris 2 episodes, 2011
- Jason Eric Gordon
- Â Stoneman #3 2 episodes, 2011
- Lucas Gerken
- Â Stoneman #5 2 episodes, 2011
- Frederik Hamel
- Â Bruce 1 episode, 2013
- Matthew Brenher
- Â The Mayor 1 episode, 2013
- Lisa Schwartz
- Â Kitty 1 episode, 2013
- Matt Calloway
- Â Apollo 1 episode, 2013
- Xander Jeanneret
- Â Axel Wolf 1 episode, 2013
- David Daskal
- Â Ace the Cerebi 1 episode, 2013
- Jeff Newman
- Â Odysseus 1 episode, 2013
- Timothy Portnoy
- Â Sweet Ray the Cyclops 1 episode, 2013
- Dane White
- Â Bob the Cerebi 1 episode, 2013
- Craig Leibowitz
- Â Mick Tooth 1 episode, 2013
- Emmanuel Todorov
- Â Hephaestus 1 episode, 2013
- Dan Sykes
- Â Chris the Cerebi 1 episode, 2013
- Christopher Peralta
- Â Jimmy Fangdrix 1 episode, 2013
- Savanna Parra
- Â Atlanta the Nymph 1 episode, 2013
- Patrick Saxon
- Â Chronos 1 episode, 2015
- Brian Sockwell
- Â Tip the Mormos 1 episode, 2013
- Lucas Schrock
- Â Hal 1 episode, 2015
- Thomas Hennessy
- Â Tom the Mormos 1 episode, 2013
- Hilary Bass
- Â Dorothy the Witch 1 episode, 2015
- Riya Ray
- Â Kali the Destroyer 1 episode, 2013
- Elisabeth Tsubota
- Â Buffy the Witch 1 episode, 2015
- Hannah Richter
- Â Cordelia the Witch 1 episode, 2015
- Nicole Erb
- Â Nymph #1 1 episode, 2010
- Carly-Ann Giene
- Â Nymph #2 1 episode, 2010
- Aileen Burdock
- Â Lourdes 1 episode, 2015
