- Mike Allrad
- Self - referee
- Tom Carter
- Reckless Youth- The Black T-Shirt Squad
- Scott Colton
- Colt Cabana - The Gold Bond Mafia
- Dragonfly
- Self
- Bradley Fry
- Mister Zero
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked- The Night Shift
- Ronald Grams
- Ichabod Slayne- The Night Shift
- Mike Kruel
- Kid Kruel
- Love Bug
- Self - Beauty and the Beast
- Zane Madrox
- Self
- Marshall Law
- Self - Beauty and the Beast
- Don Montoya
- Self - The Black T-Shirt Squad
- CM Punk
- CM Punk - The Gold Bond Mafia
- Bryce Remsburg
- Self - ring announcer / commentator
- Brock Singleton
- Self
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush - The Black T-Shirt Squad / Commentator
- Chris Spradlin
- Chris Hero- The Gold Bond Mafia
- Paul Turner
- Self - referee
- Ultramantis Black
- UltraMantis
- Matt Vandal
- Self
- Timothy P. Vassa
- Blind Rage- The Night Shift
- DJ Skittlez
- Self
