- Don Adelberg
- Donn E. Allen / 'Donn E. Criss'
- Bill Alfonso
- Bill Alfonso
- Matt Anoai
- Mack Daddy Kane- The Samoan Gangsta Party
- Sam Anoai
- Sammy the Silk- The Samoan Gangsta Party
- Bob Artese
- Self - ring announcer
- Terry Brunk
- Sabu
- Mike Bucci
- Super Nova / 'Nova Frehley' (as Michael Bucci)
- Crowbar
- Devon Storm
- Shane Douglas
- 'The Franchise' Shane Douglas
- Tommy Dreamer
- Self
- Anthony Durante
- Pitbull #2
- Francine Fournier
- Francine
- Jim Fullington
- The Sandman
- Lori Fullington
- Self
- Tyler Fullington
- Self
- Joel Gertner
- Self - ring announcer
- Brian Harris
- Brian Lee
- Don Harris
- Don Bruise
- Ron Harris
- Ron Bruise
- Trisa Hayes
- Beulah McGillicutty
- Brian Heffron
- The Blue Meanie / 'Meanie Simmons'
- John Hindley
- Johnny Smith
- Devon Hughes
- D-Von Dudley
- Chris Jericho
- Chris Jericho
- Alexandra Kane
- Lady Alexandra
- Damien Kane
- Self
- Brian Knighton
- Axl Rotten
- John Kronus
- John Kronus - The Eliminators
- Scott Levy
- Raven
- Michael Manna
- Stevie Richards / 'Stevie Stanley'
- Louis Mucciolo
- Louie Spicolli
- Jamal Mustafa
- Mustafa Saied- The Gangstas
- Perry Saturn
- Perry Saturn - The Eliminators
- Charles Scaggs
- 2 Cold Scorpio
- Peter Senerchia
- Taz
- John Smith
- J.T. Smith
- Joey Styles
- Joey Styles
- Rob Van Dam
- Rob Van Dam
- Mikey Whipwreck
- Mikey Whipwreck
- Steve Williams
- 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams
- Gary Wolf
- Pitbull #1
- Jerome Young
- New Jack- The Gangstas
