- Lily Alterman
- Sir Bedivere / Grendel's Mother / Mariam / Nick Caraway / Dracula (voice)
- Rasika Ananthraja
- Boo (Weird Sister #2) / Baby #1 / Idiot #1 (voice)
- Carli Barron
- Morgan (Weird Sister #1) / Lady Macbeth / Pinocchio (voice)
- Cade Boguslaw
- Captain Ishmael / The Seagull (voice)
- Grace Bonnell
- Banquo / Nana / Queen Elizabeth / Teenage Girl #2 (voice)
- Sarah Conder
- Sir Morderd / Dr. Jekyll / Mr. Hyde / Jay Gatsby / Oedipus (voice)
- Karen Cuizapa-Cruceno
- Jalil / Mariable Rivera (voice)
- Hollyn Dunn
- Waffle House Employee #1
- Hannah Forness
- Adam Frankenstein (Frankenstein's Monster) / Jean ValJean (voice)
- Nex Grigg
- Baby #2 / Idiot #2 (voice)
- Lainey Hammon
- James Corden / Paul Blart Mall Cop (voice)
- Becca Higby
- Waffle House Employee #2
- Brennan Huffman
- Shrek / Texan #1 / Captain Robert Walton (voice)
- Grace Hulse
- Beowulf / Quincy. P Morris (voice)
- Ben Iascu
- Mrs. Evan / Tom Sawyer / Anton Chekhov (voice)
- Zeline Igacio
- Maidservant / Reporter / Random Citizen of Herat #1 (voice)
- Emmett Lashbrook
- Henry Clerval / Sherlock Holmes (voice)
- Landon Lwea
- Random Citizen of Herat #2
- Abby Mitchell
- Winfred (Weird Sister #3) / Viola / Alexander Hamilton / Lifeguard (voice)
- Alicia Mollica
- Teenage Girl #1 / Captain Nemo (voice)
- Mj Mularski
- Jack Mularski / Jesus Christ / Rasheed (as Jack Mularski)
- Olivia Overby
- Mr. White / Juliet (voice)
- Genesis Perez
- Algernon Moncrieff / Prince Charles / Old Man / Cabbage Merchant / Genesis Perez / Aaron Burr (voice)
- Emma Rombold
- King Arthur / Lady Bracknell / Bryan Stevenson / New Yorker (voice)
- Saywer Sells
- Victor Frankenstein / Elie Wiesel (voice)
- Jack Shearin
- Meyer Wolfsheim / Mall Worker / Romeo (voice)
- Emma Claire Shelton
- Random Citizen of Herat #3
- Margo Smith
- Macbeth
- Brandon Tiseo
- Lane / Jack Worthing / Earnest Worthing / Mayor Toro (voice)
- Lethe Zenes
- Icarus / Jesse Pinkman / God (voice)
