- Katie Marovitch
- Katie
- Kerry Barker
- Kerry
- Lulu McClatchy
- Maggie May
- Katrina Mathers
- Sam
- Sara Fletcher
- Justine
- Michael Dickson
- Ira
- Olivia Castanho
- Lily
- Chris O'Brien
- Brian
- Christopher van der Meer
- Ollie
- Dakota Payne
- The Driver
- Taryn O'Neill
- Livecaster #1
- Tyler Wiseman
- Livecaster #2
- Christopher Dietrick
- Michael
- Matt Pascua
- Daniel
- Elsa Gay
- Ava
- Allie Gallerani
- Computer
- Jackie Albano
- Rachel (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Mayanna Berrin
- Lola (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Courtney Dobbs
- Jenny (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Brooke Markham
- Ginny (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Alan Maxson
- The Big Bad (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Lindsey McDowell
- Shannon (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Taylor Plecity
- Sally (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Alexandra Stamler
- Fiona (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Yasmine Vega
- The Final Girl (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
- Carly Woods
- Estelle (segment "The Final Girl Returns")
