- Saoirse Ronan
- Lady Bird McPherson
- Laurie Metcalf
- Marion McPherson
- Tracy Letts
- Larry McPherson
- Lucas Hedges
- Danny O'Neill
- Timothée Chalamet
- Kyle Scheible
- Beanie Feldstein
- Julie Steffans
- Lois Smith
- Sister Sarah Joan
- Stephen McKinley Henderson
- Father Leviatch
- Odeya Rush
- Jenna Walton
- Jordan Rodrigues
- Miguel McPherson
- Marielle Scott
- Shelly Yuhan
- John Karna
- Greg Anrue
- Jake McDorman
- Mr. Bruno
- Bayne Gibby
- Casey Kelly
- Laura Marano
- Diana Greenway
- Marietta DePrima
- Miss Patty
- Daniel Zovatto
- Jonah Ruiz
- Kristen Cloke
- Ms. Steffans
- Andy Buckley
- Uncle Matthew
- Paul Keller
- Parish Priest
- Kathryn Newton
- Darlene Bell
- Myra Turley
- Sister Gina
- Bob Stephenson
- Father Walther
- Abhimanyu Katyal
- Friendly Banker
- Chris Witaske
- Business Jock
- Ben Konigsberg
- David from College
- Gurpreet Gill
- Convenience Store Clerk
- Richard Jin
- Cool Coffee Manager
- Joan Patricia O'Neil
- Danny's Grandmother
- Robert Figueroa
- Cast Removal Doctor
- Carla Valentine
- Guidance Counselor
- Roman Arabia
- Luis Cruz
- Monique Edwards
- NYC Nurse
- Matthew Maher
- NYC Man on Street
- Anita Kalathara
- Prom Chairwoman
- Debra Miller
- Saleswoman Joyce
- Georgia Leva
- Senior Class Candidate
- Derek Butler
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- London Thor
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Shaelan O'Connor
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Christina Offley
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Sabrina Schloss
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Connor Mickiewicz
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Erik Daniells
- 'Merrily We Roll Along' Performer
- Cynthia Cales
- Immaculate Heart of Mary Teacher
- Giselle Grams
- Immaculate Heart of Mary Teacher
- Ithamar Enriquez
- Driving Instructor
- Luisa Lee
- Young Lady
- Danielle Macdonald
- Another Young Lady
- Adam Brock
- Band Lead Singer
- Bonnie Jean Shelton
- Fab 40s Realtor
- Rebecca Light
- Mr. Bruno's Wife
- Adriana Becerril
- College Girl
- Joseph Bell
- Prom Date
- Beau Bielski
- Photographed Prom Goer
- Stephen Dill
- ER Doctor
- Sheila Ellis
- Airport Business Traveler
- Nick Fenske
- Airport Business Traveler
- Sedona Feretto
- Jenna's Friend
- Keenan Johnston
- Thrift Shopper
- Rebecca Knight
- Catholic School Girl
- Suzanne LaChasse
- School Girl
- Elester Latham
- Airport Business Traveler
- Emily Merlin
- Prom Girl
- Maxx Morando
- Drummer
- Jessica Nunez-Wood
- Student
- Brian Sampson
- Prospective Home-Buyer
- Janet Song
- Administrator
- Nicole Torres
- Prom Photo Girl
- Brian VanGeem
- Prom Photographer
- Carolyn Wilson
- Supervisor
- Tomomi Yoshida
- Mother in Hospital