- Klinton Spilsbury
- The Lone Ranger / John Reid
- Michael Horse
- Tonto
- Christopher Lloyd
- Cavendish
- Matt Clark
- Sheriff Wiatt
- Juanin Clay
- Amy Striker
- Jason Robards
- President Grant
- John Bennett Perry
- Dan Reid
- David Hayward
- Ranger Collins
- John Hart
- Lucas Striker
- Richard Farnsworth
- Wild Bill Hickok
- Lincoln Tate
- General Custer
- Theodore J. Flicker
- Buffalo Bill Cody
- Marc Gilpin
- Young John Reid
- Patrick Montoya
- Young Tonto
- David Bennett
- General Rodriguez
- Rick Traeger
- German passenger
- James Bowman
- The Gambler
- Kit Wong
- Chinese passenger
- Daniel Nunez
- Waystation agent
- R.L. Tolbert
- Stagecoach driver
- Clay Boss
- Shotgun
- Jose Rey Toledo
- First chief
- Max Cisneros
- Second chief
- Ted White
- Mr. Reid
- Chere Rae
- Mrs. Reid
- James Lee Crite
- Waiter
- Jim Burk
- Ranger Stephenson
- Jeff Ramsey
- Ranger Alcott
- Bennie E. Dobbins
- Ranger Lopez
- Henry Wills
- Ranger Little
- Greg Walker
- Ranger Rankin
- Michael Adams
- Ranger Palmer
- Ben Bates
- Ranger Post
- Bill Hart
- Ranger Carner
- Larry Randles
- Ranger Stacy
- Bob Hoy
- Perlmutter (Cavendish gang)
- Ted Gehring
- Dale Wesley Stillwell (Cavendish gang)
- Buck Taylor
- Robert Edward Gattlin (Cavendish gang)
- Tom R. Diaz
- Eastman (Cavendish gang)
- Chuck Hayward
- Wald (Cavendish gang)
- Tom Laughlin
- Neeley (Cavendish gang)
- Terry Leonard
- Valentine (Cavendish gang)
- Steve Meador
- Russell (Cavendish gang)
- Joe Finnegan
- Westlake (Cavendish gang)
- Roy Bonner
- Richardson (Cavendish gang)
- John M. Smith
- Whitloff (Cavendish gang)
- Merle Haggard
- Balladeer
- Bonita Granville
- Woman
- James Keach
- The Lone Ranger / John Reid (voice) (uncredited)
- Ken Lingad
- Pablo / Manuel (uncredited)
