- David Howard Thornton
- The Mean One
- Krystle Martin
- Cindy
- Chase Mullins
- Deputy Burke
- John Bigham
- Doc Zeus
- Erik Baker
- Sheriff Hooper
- Flip Kobler
- Lou
- Amy Schumacher
- Mayor McBean
- Tina Van Berk
- Mom
- Saphina Chanadet
- Young Cindy
- Victoria Ippolito
- Waitress Emily
- Alexandra Vaughan
- Hiker Girl
- Jessie Holder Tourtellotte
- Anchorwoman
- Allyson Sereboff
- Nurse
- Rachel Winfree
- Bartender
- Whit Spurgeon
- Bus Driver
- Christine DiTillio
- Mrs. Hunter
- Ernie Charles
- EMT
- Robert DiTillio
- Diner Owner
- Stephanie Bates
- Flashback Victim
- Josh Arnold
- Delivery Driver
- Steven Busby
- Anchorman
- Brian Waters
- Dick Santa
- Andrew Fultz
- Dick Santa 2
- Aubrey Mozino
- Christmas Box Influencer
- Christopher Sanders
- Narrator
- Tehana Weeks
- Doctor
- Molly Flanagan
- Ms. Claus Influencer
- Erik Anthony Russo
- Naked Santa
- Leon Sheen
- Drunken Elf
- Kale Shepherd
- Santa Con Santa