- John Wayne
- Steve Williams
- Donna Reed
- Alice Singleton
- Charles Coburn
- Father Burke
- Tom Tully
- Father Malone
- Sherry Jackson
- Carol Williams
- Marie Windsor
- Anne McCormick
- Tom Helmore
- Harold McCormick
- Dabbs Greer
- Father Peterson
- Leif Erickson
- Father Provincial
- Douglas Spencer
- Father Procurator
- Lester Matthews
- Cardinal O'Shea
- Chuck Connors
- Stan Schwegler
- John Alban
- Football Spectator
- Murray Alper
- Bus Driver
- Brandon Beach
- Football Spectator
- Arthur Berkeley
- Waiter
- Beatrice Bernadine
- Minor Role
- Oscar Blank
- Pool Hall Patron
- Oran Breeland
- Minor Role
- John Breen
- Clerk
- Phil Chambers
- Bishop
- Keith Clarke
- Scholastic
- Doris Cole
- Redhead
- Dolly Cooper
- Minor Role
- James Dean
- Football Spectator
- Martin Dean
- Minor Role
- Ted Eckelberry
- Joe Ostrow
- Frank Ferguson
- Mike Edwards
- Henry Fladwed
- Minor Role
- James Flavin
- Coach Buck Holman
- Fritz Ford
- Football Player
- Joan Freeman
- Minor Role
- Curt Furberg
- Football Spectator
- Jack Gargan
- Bailiff
- Richard Garrick
- Judge
- Kenneth Gibson
- Priest
- Ned Glass
- Steve's Pool Opponent
- James Gonzalez
- Party Guest
- Fred Graham
- Bill Sackheim
- Merv Griffin
- Football Broadcaster
- Jack Henderson
- Clerk
- Tom Hernández
- Butler
- Harry Hines
- Minor Role
- Pete Kellett
- Football Player
- Robert Keys
- Santa Carla Team Manager Joe
- Paul Kruger
- Bailiff
- Ray Kyle
- Student
- Joseph La Cava
- Bar Patron
- Mike Lally
- Priest
- Frank Marlowe
- Drunk in Bar with Dog
- Sydney Mason
- Priest
- Frank McLure
- Priest
- Tina Menard
- Woman at Domestic Relations
- Larry Merrill
- Jeffrey Marlowe
- Melly Merrill
- Minor Role
- Martin Milner
- Football Recruit
- Pat Mitchell
- Minor Role
- Jack Mower
- Domestic Relations Court Staffer
- Anton Northpole
- Pool Hall Patron
- Barry Norton
- Party Guest
- William H. O'Brien
- Bartender Joe
- Melody O'Connor
- Minor Role
- Jack Pepper
- Irish Tenor / Pianist in Saloon (uncredited)
- Billy Perna
- Minor Role
- Jack Perrin
- Ticket Purchaser
- Howard Petrie
- Marvin Adams
- Angi O. Poulos
- Saloon Waiter
- Vici Raaf
- Beanie
- Bill Radovich
- Moose McCall - Assistant Coach
- Bernard Sell
- Clerk
- Olan Soule
- Cardinal's Secretary
- Norman Stevans
- Party Guest
- Anitra Stevens
- Bobo
- Arthur Tovey
- Football Spectator
- Renata Vanni
- Maria's Mother
- Ralph Volkie
- Referee
- Charles Watts
- Mr. Wallace
- Guy Way
- Football Player
- Jeri Weil
- Young Carol
- Gayne Whitman
- Grummet
